Patrick Mahomes vs. Deshaun Watson: Which QB is more valuable to their team? | First Take

  • Published: 10 January 2020
  • Stephen A. Smith, Max Kellerman and Marcus Spears weigh in on whether Houston Texans Deshaun Watson or Kansas City Chiefs Patrick Mahomes is the more valuable QB to their team.
    #FirstTake #NFL
    ✔ Subscribe to ESPN+
    ✔ Get the ESPN App:
    ✔ Subscribe to ESPN on YouTube:
    ✔ Subscribe to ESPN FC on YouTube:
    ✔ Subscribe to NBA on ESPN on YouTube:
    ✔ Watch ESPN on YouTube TV:

    Exclusive interviews with Rachel Nichols
    Stephen A. Smith on ESPN

    ESPN on Social Media:
    ► Follow on Twitter:
    ► Like on Facebook:
    ► Follow on Instagram:

    Visit ESPN on YouTube to get up-to-the-minute sports news coverage, scores, highlights and commentary for NFL, NHL, MLB, NBA, College Football, NCAA Basketball, soccer and more.

    More on
  • Sport Sport

Comments • 768

  • Michael Jordan
    Michael Jordan  2 days back

    mahomes, alex smith couldn’t make those weapons work. mahomes can.

    • Captain Obvious
      Captain Obvious  3 days back


      • peterfrknpan
        peterfrknpan  3 days back

        Sas. Shut up. What Patrick does, outside the pocket is not design. The throes he makes. Across his body. Running in the opposite direction. No look That is not coaching.

        • Darth Maul
          Darth Maul  5 days back

          Mahones just threw 51 points and y’all gonna day Watson is better smh 🤦‍♂️ I

          • Ivan Alvarado
            Ivan Alvarado  5 days back

            Why did Fitzpatrick play for the Texans

            • Les Davis
              Les Davis  6 days back

              Here's a kicker:
              If the QBs in question switched teams, would Mahomes have such great numbers? Would Watson blow the roof off the stats? If the answer to either is "no", then you have your answer as to who is more valuable. IJS

              • Tee Jones
                Tee Jones  6 days back

                Deshaun Watson has to coach as well as play so I give it to #4

                • brianminkc
                  brianminkc  7 days back

                  First thing Deshaun did this morning was apply for food stamps.

                  • CrushingRock
                    CrushingRock  7 days back

                    No molly is a breath of fresh air

                    • idiots guide productions

                      Lol Alex Smith who ?

                      • Shawn Pavlik
                        Shawn Pavlik  7 days back

                        I'm going to go with MAHOMES.

                        • Tom Gow
                          Tom Gow  7 days back

                          Stephan A and marcus argument is all predicated on replacing pat Mahomes with Alex smith and the chiefs would still be in the playoffs, so the same with Watson and so would the Texans. Smith is still a amazing QB and can carry any team

                          • Raynon Oubre
                            Raynon Oubre  1 weeks back

                            Max is smarter than Stephen a

                            • Alan Snyder
                              Alan Snyder  1 weeks back

                              They need to get ride of max. The dudes a joke!

                              • Antoine Bracy
                                Antoine Bracy  1 weeks back

                                Both of these youngsters are a joy to watch play!

                                • Robert Lopez
                                  Robert Lopez  1 weeks back

                                  This debate ended today! Don’t bring it up ever again. Watson is good. Mahomes is great. End of story

                                  • DA31D
                                    DA31D  1 weeks back

                                    Ngl Max was so right...

                                    • facepalm015
                                      facepalm015  1 weeks back

                                      Can't wait for them to revisit this topic Monday lol

                                      • JLopez
                                        JLopez  1 weeks back

                                        We all arguing about Watson vs Mahomes but as a Texans fan let me tell you some 😂😂 aren’t we and the Chiefs happy that the fucking Bears passed up on these 2 monsters to take a dude that played one good season. I know today they were pulling out their hair while we were watching the next Brady vs Manning 2.0.

                                        • Bobby Hill
                                          Bobby Hill  1 weeks back

                                          Ohhhhh yeaaaa. No more air guitar. Nothing better then seeing watson sulking on the sideline. Thank u pat for ending that guys season.

                                          • ZadfrackGlutz Zesozose
                                            ZadfrackGlutz Zesozose  1 weeks back

                                            Brother under a fern.

                                            • Marty Holmes
                                              Marty Holmes  1 weeks back

                                              Who here after pat Mahomes showed it is a difference between good season quarterbacks and every season quarterbacks ✌🏾🤷🏾

                                              • MrBlue3rd
                                                MrBlue3rd  1 weeks back

                                                Marty Holmes 🙋🏻‍♂️

                                            • AlphaDog 104
                                              AlphaDog 104  1 weeks back

                                              Bruh Max is a lil special sometimes

                                              • Juan Pablo Moreno Ruiz
                                                Juan Pablo Moreno Ruiz  1 weeks back

                                                That didnt age all.

                                                • Mack Peters
                                                  Mack Peters  1 weeks back

                                                  Every case they made for watson is the same for mahomes. Hes way better than alex smith. If he missed the year then the chiefs wouldn’t make the playoffs

                                                  • nathan d
                                                    nathan d  1 weeks back

                                                    Today, Magic Mahomes showed that when the Chiefs are down 21-0, the chiefs can explode and put up 50 points!!
                                                    What I hate is when they r like Oo Mahomes has this or that player, Mahomes is still special and stop making reasons why u ( Stephen A or skippy doe I day skip bay less) can’t except that Mahomes is a badddddddd dude.

                                                    • eli wol
                                                      eli wol  1 weeks back

                                                      Both of these guys are good but I don’t particularly like Mahomes. I had the unpleasant experience of meeting his girlfriend. I was at an event of mostly Princeton Alumni as well as current students, and his girlfriend was at a different event in the same building. She actually tried to have security make everyone get off an elevator and clear a lobby because some kids heckled her. She was nasty, and she made disparaging comments to the students calling them poor, and then bragged about her car.

                                                      • Trill J
                                                        Trill J  1 weeks back

                                                        It’s crazy how max did not even answer the question or comprehend it. The question was which quarter black is more valuable to their team! Not which qb is better or which one you rather have! 🤦🏽‍♂️ it’s clearly Watson. Mahomes is better but not more valuable to his team then Watson is to his.

                                                        • Ty Polson
                                                          Ty Polson  1 weeks back

                                                          IMO Watson not as good a runner as Lamar not as good a thrower as Mahomes but he’s great at both

                                                          • Reese Ross
                                                            Reese Ross  1 weeks back

                                                            Today doesn't look good for the chiefs posting this watching the game now bummer for the chiefs as usual.

                                                          • berkslaw
                                                            berkslaw  1 weeks back

                                                            Do I HEAR BOOOO BIRDS out in K.C.?

                                                            • Myron Jr
                                                              Myron Jr  1 weeks back

                                                              Watson 7-0 🤔

                                                              • Myron Jr
                                                                Myron Jr  1 weeks back

                                                                League MVP five times

                                                              • Myron Jr
                                                                Myron Jr  1 weeks back

                                                                Pro bowl fourteen times

                                                              • Myron Jr
                                                                Myron Jr  1 weeks back

                                                                Champion two times

                                                              • Vaerah
                                                                Vaerah  1 weeks back

                                                                @Myron Jr Peyton Who?

                                                              • Myron Jr
                                                                Myron Jr  1 weeks back

                                                                Will Patrick pull a Peyton Manning?

                                                            • Cesar Torres
                                                              Cesar Torres  1 weeks back

                                                              Life is simple no molly I like the video

                                                              • Francisco Quezada
                                                                Francisco Quezada  1 weeks back

                                                                This analysts are garbage , Moore got us wins when Patrick was down

                                                                • BedWarsChallenger -MinecraftAndMore

                                                                  Alex is dumb as heck

                                                                  • Demetrius Jones
                                                                    Demetrius Jones  1 weeks back

                                                                    Chiefs will be eaten alive if they beat Houston. Titans are playing to their name

                                                                    • Angel Cadena
                                                                      Angel Cadena  1 weeks back

                                                                      Also max srsly needs to stop shifting the topic. This isn't bout stats idiot. ITS bout who is MORE valuable. Meaning which QB carries the most weight for the team.

                                                                      • Angel Cadena
                                                                        Angel Cadena  1 weeks back

                                                                        This rivalry is soon to be the greatest of all time. But for now it still belongs to Peyton vs Brady.

                                                                        • chris klein
                                                                          chris klein  1 weeks back

                                                                 about over analyzing things for the sake of conversation! That’s FIRST TAKE for ya !!!

                                                                          Simply put, KC is a bit better than HOU and should get past them today. It’s Sunday at the time I commented. KC 28-20 in that range !!!

                                                                          • MrRickostby
                                                                            MrRickostby  1 weeks back

                                                                            If the Chiefs win don't forget they lost to Tennessee earlier this year 35-32. Should be a Great Championship game!

                                                                            • The New Society
                                                                              The New Society  1 weeks back

                                                                              Bro the chiefs were great under Alex Smith. 11-5 team. Alex smith was almost an MVP with that cast. Dehsaun got hurt his rookie year and the team went from like 5-3 to 1-7 what are we even talking about here ?

                                                                              • Gerardo Lopez
                                                                                Gerardo Lopez  1 weeks back

                                                                                It's going to come down to the final minutes

                                                                                • Gerardo Lopez
                                                                                  Gerardo Lopez  1 weeks back

                                                                                  Texans vs Chiefs is going to be a good game today and a high scoring game

                                                                                  • KRYSS KAGE SHOW
                                                                                    KRYSS KAGE SHOW  1 weeks back

                                                                                    Bears stupid for missing two good QBs

                                                                                    • Jerry David
                                                                                      Jerry David  1 weeks back

                                                                                      The chiefs have been relevant every year... a top offense year in and year out.

                                                                                      Texans are far more likely to be a dumpster fire without Watson, than Chiefs without Mahomes. That said, can’t go wrong with either one .

                                                                                      • Brian Cox
                                                                                        Brian Cox  1 weeks back

                                                                                        Funny a world in which the Chiefs are the “sleeper” team. They have been the best team in the league since Mahomie got healthy.

                                                                                        • Serotoxin
                                                                                          Serotoxin  1 weeks back

                                                                                          Anyone: makes a good argument for deshuan
                                                                                          Max:you would think so

                                                                                          • Jeff Cavanaugh
                                                                                            Jeff Cavanaugh  1 weeks back

                                                                                            I love listening to Marcus Spears son Max on a near daily basis. Can we get Max on sometimes and keep Marcus on all the time with SAS?