Hong Kong: Violence intensifies as protester shot by police - BBC Newsnight

Share
HTML-code
  • Published: 01 October 2019
  • An activist involved in anti-government protests in Hong Kong has been shot in the chest by police during a clash.
    Subscribe to our channel here: https://goo.gl/31Q53F

    The protester was shot as thousands of people demonstrated in defiance of a protest ban for the 70th anniversary of Communist rule in China. Though people have been shot by rubber bullets in previous protests, this is the first injury from a live round.

    In the Chinese capital Beijing, 15,000 soldiers paraded with advanced military hardware to mark the anniversary.

    Nearly four months of protests in Hong Kong have challenged Chinese President Xi Jinping's vision of national unity.

    International editor Gabriel Gatehouse and cameraman Jack Garland report from Hong Kong. In the studio Emily Maitlis is joined by MP Bob Seely and Steve Tsang, director of the China institute at SOAS.

    Newsnight is the BBC's flagship news and current affairs TV programme - with analysis, debate, exclusives, and robust interviews.

    Website: https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsnight
    Twitter: https://twitter.com/BBCNewsnight
    Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/bbcnewsnight

Comments • 500

  • swetab singh
    swetab singh  1 months back

    I feel like bhagat singh speaking

    • Tek Chong
      Tek Chong  1 months back

      If they would attack me when I am in my car, I would run all of them over.

    • Ken Gore
      Ken Gore  1 months back

      can you believe that ? china is richer than hong kong, should give you pause next time you oppose capitalism for socialist/ communism

      • lancelot F.X
        lancelot F.X  2 months back

        is there to much spotlight over protesters, which is only roughly 1.2 M ppl, what the rest ppl think about this ? Democracy, should it be in the hands of more ppl? the rest over 4 million ppl there?

        • John Doe
          John Doe  2 months back

          The only thing these rioters has achieved and shown to the China is that "one country, two systems" does not work. All this will come back in 2047 to haunt the Hong Kong youths of this generation....especially those who have been arrested (whether or not they are charged). Unlike many of their leaders who already have foreign nationality as fallback, all these brainwashed youths will not be as fortunate.

          Hong Kong riot is never about freedom. It is all about advancing self-interest, nothing else. The benefactor is clear from the actions and rhetoric of the one Big Brother that is actively behind the violence.

          • John Doe
            John Doe  2 months back

            It's rioters who turned violent first before police retaliating with equal or greater force. PEACEFUL protest, ZERO police action. PERIOD. See beyond the propaganda and biased media, the truth is police will only respond in kind when these protestors turn into violent rioters.

            • John Doe
              John Doe  2 months back

              No need to entertain any more demand. You don't want these thugs to be the future of Hong Kong. No thanks to this brand of lawless democraZy. It is about time to throw out the trash

              • Dai Mao
                Dai Mao  2 months back

                For the those confident in the police check out Black Head Down

                • Jo Chan
                  Jo Chan  2 months back

                  2019.11.11 rioters burnd a 57yrs man
                  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Y5RtecvZSc
                  0:54 starts - but blacken in screen coz youtube will remove it out.
                  it is believed a 5th degree burn, and survival rate is extremely low.
                  this the HK rioter....actually they are terriorist.
                  they burning down HK.

                  • Maggie Zhu
                    Maggie Zhu  2 months back

                    Why HK protester wear and act as terrorists on streets! Very professional!
                    Man! Special “ HK democracy” is attacking people at airport, subway, fire in public and attacking police! 🤣🤣🤣

                    • Aaron How
                      Aaron How  3 months back

                      Fuck the elites who try turning our lives to fucking shit.

                      • John Doe
                        John Doe  3 months back

                        Yes, Free Hong Kong…..


                        ……
                        from these paid rioters and sponsored terrorists.

                        • George Kwong
                          George Kwong  3 months back

                          Hong Kong is a blessed place, the most free place, People are free to enter and exit, Funds are free to enter and exit,... Business can be freely traded, Renminbi, foreign currency can be freely circulated, What financial products are available, all can be freely traded, and what financial products are spurred by the enthusiasm of the dream is developed, the double exhibition is small, and the financial thugs are tempting. Hong Kong is a spy paradise, which is the great value of Hong Kong. Hong Kong's wealth is a financing center. Hong Kong is an interest group (black and white), and property hegemony has plundered huge wealth. Hong Kong's surplus value, everyone loves it, Hong Kong's status is rock solid, value is incomparable, what are you worried about? ? Nowadays, there is wine now drunk!

                          • Wong Siaw Jin
                            Wong Siaw Jin  3 months back

                            It all depends on your action, kid. So as you need to face the consequences, do not blame police or anyone of your death in the chicken fight way. From the first day you have joined, you are risking yourself to dangers, anything could happen and you need courage and be responsible of yourself. You guys always say fighting for democracy but how much did you know about democracy? Where is your senses of the real democracy? I respect your freedom in the name of democracy if you do respect others freedom to choose. I respect your democracy if you not using violence to take things above law. Zero tolerance to violence by any means.

                            • Seymour Butts
                              Seymour Butts  3 months back

                              Tired of reading so many of the comments that are biased, misinformed and just untrue. Also, tired of seeing Ms. Carrie Lam ignore reality. She can end this protest at any time by actually doing her job and trying to reach a diplomatic solution. Peace.

                              • YKH Lee
                                YKH Lee  3 months back

                                For real? It's easier said than done.

                                • SpaceCookie85
                                  SpaceCookie85  3 months back

                                  HONG KONG DESERVES A BETTER DEMOCRACY.

                                  **HONG KONG DESERVES BETTER THAN WHAT IS HAPPENING TO THEM**

                                  I fully support these protests. Go Hong Kong!!

                                  • burants
                                    burants  3 months back

                                    Emily Matiss ya traitor to the British people get off our screens...bring back John Cleese

                                    • Tommy Tan
                                      Tommy Tan  3 months back

                                      Very good reporting by BBC. Why don't you report and suggest to bring all these former British Subjects back to Britain. You sound very sympathetic to these Protesters.
                                      Please go and report the recent Iraq Protests where almost a hundred were shot and killed.
                                      They are a Democratic Country with free elections and Hong Kong is not .... how many are shot and killed in Hong Kong?

                                      • A A
                                        A A  3 months back

                                        To the “front-line protestors“ who said they are willing to die, why don’t you ask their family how they feel ?
                                        He said that “they don’t have control on the police how he will get shot”, why not ask him “doesn’t he has control of his actions?”. You will not be shot if you protest peacefully.
                                        Agreed with both of John Doe comments. Spot on.

                                        • Nerd Mysteria
                                          Nerd Mysteria  3 months back

                                          The Police just act weak now cuz the protesters aren’t peaceful. They’re weak and cant fight unless they’re attacking peaceful demonstrators. During the umbrella revolution, a movement during 2013 or 2014, they beat peaceful protesters into a bloody mess. Protesters often got beat just for trying to move forward. And the same stuff happened on June 12th 2019, around the beginning of the protests, when HK Police attacked peaceful protesters and random people and sparked violent reactions from obviously angry demonstrators. Examples include them pepper spraying some guy with a blue jacket sitting down on the sidewalk, shooting a protester in the head with rubber bullets, attacking an unconscious protester, etc. Throughout July, there were organized mob attacks by gangsters hired by HK Police, undercover police pretending to be protesters by vandalizing and attacking other police, sexually harassing an arrested girl, shooting tear gas at an elementary school student, and much more. Peaceful protests don’t work if you’re fighting against a stubborn tyrant

                                      • John Doe
                                        John Doe  3 months back

                                        Hong Kong needs independent, level-headed, impartial arbitrators, who have Hong Kong best interest in mind, to work out an amiable solution for the current crisis. They need to establish some common grounds where both sides could accept. Hong Kong long term prospective lies more with Beijing on what role the city would continue to play.

                                        • John Doe
                                          John Doe  3 months back

                                          These sponsored thugs and rioters are suppressing the opposing voice of true Hong Kong population. No thanks to these sponsored thugs who appeared to be worse than Nazis and Red Guards. Hong Kong has been peaceful and orderly before these thugs showed up. It would help to return Hong Kong back to normality if these rioting could stop so that the authority could de-escalate their actions. It would also help if the media is less biased in their coverage. They should be covering the news and not making it.

                                          As far as history and the future are concerned, HK has been, is and will always be part of China. The only things that HK should truly treasure are its enterprising people, unique culture, institutional system with the rule of law, and infrastructure. Without these core assets, the society will not survive regardless of political system.

                                          • John Doe
                                            John Doe  3 months back

                                            Individual can always have a difference on opinion. However, press coverage must maintain its impartiality. If it is simply the view of the reporter, then it must not be disguised as news but rather his or her own opinion piece since the content is probably filtered to justify one side or the other. The current situation in Hong Kong is that these sponsored thugs have infiltrated the "press". Every tom-dick-and-harry can get a press pass for $30 as independent online "reporter". The international media would just ride on these opinion pieces as facts or sources for their reporting.

                                            https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZoBXEjDk0VU

                                          • Seymour Butts
                                            Seymour Butts  3 months back

                                            Your comment is an example of bias.

                                        • Lee Qing
                                          Lee Qing  3 months back

                                          Their job is not to report the news, but to discredit China. At least they did a good job.

                                          • Titus P
                                            Titus P  3 months back

                                            The irony : people in China have limited or biased information but they are able to decipher much of the truth ....on the other hand BBC reporter and anchor may have first hand information and can’t understand the situation.

                                            Watch this to better understand https://youtu.be/un8ksFETvtc

                                            • 施马克
                                              施马克  3 months back

                                              You must be kidding to think that the current generation of mainland Chinese can be hijacked of their ability to breach the firewall and see for themselves what is actually happening in Hong Kong. Just by having a British's Chinese Pedigree sitting in your interview doesn't make you look credible. And I 'like' the fact you still persist in using the word "authoritarian" in China. Yes, they are authoritarian, but not to their people but rather from influence like you BBC that distorts the truth. An authoritarian leadership will only lead to a North Korea country, not the current rich and influential status of current China. Don't waste time trying to teach China how to build a civilization. You should spend more time preparing for the coming Europe riots when the next world economy collapse comes as USA crisis slowly unveiled itself in the coming 2020. I will sure enjoy seeing how you handle 'peaceful protests' on my sofa with the pop-corn.

                                              • 施马克
                                                施马克  3 months back

                                                Hey British, bring your rubbish back and please define peaceful, BBC

                                                • CYM 1
                                                  CYM 1  3 months back

                                                  die is ok but why how is not ok , die stupidly throwing bomb that it.

                                                  • Jum saesiaw
                                                    Jum saesiaw  3 months back

                                                    F****** BIASED NETWORK. I was a fan of this network for thirty years. I have heard of the biased reporters ..but I don’t have proof...not until what is happening here in Hong Kong, because I live here, but not just that... I never take sides because I’m a foreigner here. But I judged from what I see with my own eyes every days, and months long...Do I have to remind you how your country treated the students who were protest about the tuition fee? My wish here for you. I wanted to see your country in a more turmoil...And another WAR WITH THE IRISH.

                                                    • Logan Beri
                                                      Logan Beri  3 months back

                                                      Hong Kong police are the greatest. Report objectively. Your reports are bias towards the rioters and criminals. How can anyone believe BBC nowadays, even when they report something legitimate.

                                                      • Peter Hsieh
                                                        Peter Hsieh  3 months back

                                                        It is interesting to see the kid get shoot by police asking police to save him?!

                                                        • Kim Seong Lau
                                                          Kim Seong Lau  3 months back

                                                          BBC is very irresponsible glorifying and dramatizing rioting.What if this happened in your own country?

                                                          • T G
                                                            T G  3 months back

                                                            Kim Seong Lau do you know what the 5 things are which they are demanding?

                                                        • Treasures of Sin
                                                          Treasures of Sin  3 months back

                                                          So, what do these people are trying to achive by confronting the police? They decide nothing. They just go to show off and run away from police. Why no to attack the houses of people who make decision?

                                                          • onizuka sensei
                                                            onizuka sensei  3 months back

                                                            There are quite number of Chinese communist sympathizers in this comment section. Nonetheless, I will say clearly that the Chinese government is a corrupt, brutal and tyrannical regime that oppresses it's people through the threat of force and active psychological manipulation. The reason people do not speak in opposition their is either fear, ignorance, brainwashing or all of the above.

                                                            • Lady Harriet
                                                              Lady Harriet  3 months back

                                                              BBC, ask yourself, would you invite these radicals to your home with your own kids??While media are not strictly educational, at least have the conscience to report how the ordinary people living in fear (you must protect their identities, rioters are notorious and determined to hunt anyone oppose them!). Because of mass biased reporting, the only way the rioters see is violence, bullying, vandalism and terrorism. Try to treat these rioters AND the ordinary HK citizens as your own children, both sides deserve to know the whole truth!!

                                                              • EPIC EMOTION
                                                                EPIC EMOTION  2 months back

                                                                BBC is a British Broadcasting service, does not need to represent the world conscience. A simple reporting to make Hong suffer is the way to compete with China, oops if people die. Weak human governments play tricks on each other, but human will be strong once they unite.

                                                            • BESI MAN
                                                              BESI MAN  3 months back

                                                              You better die..wellcome to Hong Kong...once the army coming in these idiots will die for nothing.

                                                              • dtvqa
                                                                dtvqa  3 months back

                                                                Report the truth BBC News. This should be called "a riot" not a protest. A peaceful protest doesn't involve hooligans, thugs, and criminals vandalizing properties, assaulting others of opposing views, and assaulting police officers. Failure to report facts and supporting the narrative of unlawful people is just enabling them to commit more crimes. These HK people are criminals, thugs, and hooligans. All the assaults and destruction they've committed in the last 3 months are acts of criminals. Why is BBC News biased in your reporting? These low class HK people are using the so-called "freedom & democracy" narrative to freely commit violence, vandalism, and crimes. Please do westerners a favour and report the truth. The Western media (BBC News, Global News, CTV News, and CBC News owes the Western public accountability in your reporting.

                                                                • Chetan
                                                                  Chetan  3 months back

                                                                  Indian should learn from Hong Kong's citizens.

                                                                • mperor me
                                                                  mperor me  3 months back

                                                                  Hongie let someone put a bullet in your fucked up head then

                                                                  • k 3k
                                                                    k 3k  3 months back

                                                                    TSING it's a good thing you hide your ass in the UK, you slant-eyed bastard

                                                                    • k 3k
                                                                      k 3k  3 months back

                                                                      support hong kong police shoot to kill rioters

                                                                      • Elven Ranger
                                                                        Elven Ranger  3 months back

                                                                        0:33 here's the boot licker.
                                                                        Keep suckin the commies bud, they aren't giving you a gov't job.

                                                                        • imoutodesho
                                                                          imoutodesho  3 months back

                                                                          The police is right, see the whole video of the event. Western media biased, focus on asian police shot civilian, not showing the footage
                                                                          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WmRdLMAUROE
                                                                          do the same riot in USA, Australia, UK, etc, and you will be shot, not once, but multiple times. I guarantee

                                                                          • S S
                                                                            S S  4 months back

                                                                            Protesters are not happy at all the trash stupid Chief Executives Beijing assigned. Not just them many rich businessmen also complained Beijing making "wrong choices" of senior government officials in HK which is the fundamental problem right now. Had Carrie Lam "withdrawn the bill" after 1st million people took to the streets on Jun 9 NOTHING would have happened but that bitch waited until Sep 4 before announcing withdrawal. From Jun 12 to Sep 4 thousands protesters are seriously injured, beaten up, raped tortured by police dogs with over 100 killed!!! This sort of police brutality never happened under British era. CCP has to review everything: HK is not China, HK cannot be ruled like China esp in regard to police brutality, human rights and inhumanity. Several US Congressmen are visiting HK to look into the mass slaughtering, torturing, kidnappint and rape committed by police dogs in the past months and US will put sanctions on Carrie Lam, the police chief and commie puppets. They should all go to jail to be tortured and raped in the jail just what they are now doing towards the protesters!!!

                                                                            • OurVenture 2019
                                                                              OurVenture 2019  4 months back

                                                                              https://youtu.be/FmhFqp-3g3s

                                                                              Check this technical analysis

                                                                              • didi Alice
                                                                                didi Alice  4 months back

                                                                                The whole vedio is full of Pride and Prejudice! In mainland China we do know what happen in HK.
                                                                                However, By seeing the riots beating people with different option, burning the national flags, shouting and insulting people. None of us can be convinced this is a fight for democracy and freedom!!!!

                                                                                • didi Alice
                                                                                  didi Alice  3 months back

                                                                                  S S well well, who is the blind here! Use ur brain not ur illusion, loser!

                                                                                • S S
                                                                                  S S  3 months back

                                                                                  何以 這土地 淚再流?
                                                                                  何以 令眾人 亦憤恨?
                                                                                  昂首拒默沉 吶喊聲響透
                                                                                  盼自由歸於這裡
                                                                                  何以 這恐懼 抹不走
                                                                                  何以 為信念 從沒退後
                                                                                  何解血在流 但邁進聲透
                                                                                  建自由光輝香港
                                                                                  在晚星墮落 徬徨午夜
                                                                                  迷霧裏 最遠處 吹來號角聲!
                                                                                  捍自由 來齊集這裡
                                                                                  來全力抗對勇氣智慧也永不滅……。
                                                                                  黎明來到 要光復這香港
                                                                                  同行兒女 為正義時代革命
                                                                                  祈求民主與自由 萬世都不朽
                                                                                  我願榮光歸香港!

                                                                                • S S
                                                                                  S S  3 months back

                                                                                  @Geo H Peace need not be fought for as long as HKers forced to be obedient quiet slavery ants of china criminal party exactly like the 1.4 billion ants in china, like a gun pointing at your head around the clock, once you say something bad but true about Xi Jinping or CCP you got shot at your head. Having seen the recent HK police dogs brutality slaughtering torturing raping kidnapping disappearing hundreds innocent HK citizens, the situations in china would be much worse, each day how many chinamen got killed tortured raped locked up disappeared??????? You 50centers who are licking CCP to survive have no shame, no dignity no care no respect no consideration how your fellow chinamen sacrificed and suffered under ccp. chinese people are pity pathetic people on earth!!

                                                                              • 72dew
                                                                                72dew  4 months back

                                                                                The subway wasn't closed to limit the travels of the protesters, they were closed because these rioters trashed it. Shit reporting job

                                                                                • 72dew
                                                                                  72dew  3 months back

                                                                                  @S S The typical rioter rhetoric, anyone who disagrees with your narrative is a commie

                                                                                • S S
                                                                                  S S  4 months back

                                                                                  Watch the true news and facts and not commies myths and lies!

                                                                              • Hide R
                                                                                Hide R  4 months back

                                                                                These protesters are rioters. There are so many videos of them attacking innocent people who disagree with them. They are the evil-doers. They are using violence to suppress people.

                                                                              • All Weather Cat Lover
                                                                                All Weather Cat Lover  4 months back

                                                                                3:07 That was an attempt to murder!