Is Amazon Basics better than Liqui Moly? Let's find out!

Share
HTML-code
  • Published: 08 April 2019
  • The oil competition series intensifies as Amazon Basics competes against Liqui Moly. Is the low-priced AmazonBasics full synthetic 5W-30 motor as good or better than Liqui Moly's Top Tex 4200 5W-30 full synthetic motor oil? I am not sponsored by Liqui Moly or Amazon Basics. I purchased both of these products using my own money. I am not sponsored by Amazon, Liqui Moly, or by any product manufacturer. 100% of Project Farm videos are ideas that come from those leaving comments. So, thank you very much for requesting this video!

    In the previous episodes, Amsoil won over Royal Purple and will advance to next round in the oil championship series.
    https://www.youtube.com/edit?o=U&video_id=E2zS8MyvJxU

    Red Line won over Walmart's SuperTech and will also advance: https://www.youtube.com/edit?o=U&video_id=zwqt5vI0o1A

    The testing methods outlined in this video are my own and not performed using expensive oil lab testing equipment or following the ASTM, SAE or API testing standards. The three tests outlined in the video include tests for viscosity at varying temperatures, film strength, and evaporative testing. In my opinion, the testing approaches used in this video provide consumers with valuable information on choosing the right motor oil for their specific application. Hope you enjoy the rest of the video and thank you very much for supporting the channel by watching the commercials and through Patreon support. https://www.patreon.com/projectfarm

    This video is only for entertainment purposes. If you rely on the information portrayed in this video, you assume the responsibility for the results. Project Farm LLC
  • Hobbies and Style Hobbies and Style

Comments • 5 722

  • RO _BMW
    RO _BMW  6 hours back

    Fck that, i dont trust this test. Why the fck would be a cheap oil better then a high qualitiy one. I am using only high performance oil and i drive a bmw 335i n54 with over 540 hp. I will never put a cheap oil into my engine! You can say wathever you want, put cheap oil in your car but dont complain if your engine will blow off.

    • Skilla001
      Skilla001  18 hours back

      Für diesen Test hättest du das Liqui Moly Top Tec 4600 5W-30 müssen. Noch besser währe ein Liqui Moly der Synthoilklasse!

      • Nemo
        Nemo  2 days back

        take: Liqui moly is the most overrated and overpriced oil, it's absolutely nothing special but it suckers in the german car fanboys with it's big MADE IN GERMANY labels. there are many oils available that are better AND cheaper, and many more that are just as good for less.

      • José amado Martínez
        José amado Martínez  2 days back

        Project farm you should test 2 stroke oil

      • Jesus Gonzalez
        Jesus Gonzalez  2 days back

        Could you test liqui moly molygen?

        • Jesus Gonzalez
          Jesus Gonzalez  2 days back

          Project Farm I figured it’d be a good oil to test since liqui moly claims it significantly reduces engine friction by 15% and has more additives

        • Project Farm
          Project Farm   2 days back

          Thank you for the video idea!

      • omar k
        omar k  3 days back

        do the new kirkland signature oil!!!!! 2 5 quart jugs for 30 bucks

      • mihai0377
        mihai0377  5 days back

        Amazon is the best joke ever when it comes to Shopping ! Chinese products at double the price ! Only good thing is fast delivery...but i rather wait 2 weeks and buy at Sale Price from China directly, rather than put more money into Jeff pockets for nothing ! Open your eyes people !

      • RoachKai
        RoachKai  5 days back

        2 hours?? Somebody get this man a lazy susan!

        • dymsza
          dymsza  5 days back

          i wonder if the winter test makes sense. Is the mass of the oil exactly the some in both case ? And would that affect the results

        • Jess Please.
          Jess Please.  5 days back

          You should do oil filter tests.

        • Christos Sklivas
          Christos Sklivas  6 days back

          Motul 300V F.L. test will be very interesting !!!!!!

        • Robert Schulz
          Robert Schulz  1 weeks back

          Isn't Liqui moly 5w30 4200 is a bmw ll01 oil? Meaning it's closer to a api 5w-40 with a 3.5+ hths? Amazon basics probably has a hths of 2.9?

        • lakkchina
          lakkchina  1 weeks back

          Your doesn’t tell anything. I will buy liqui moly over Amazon Oil. Nothing in your test show scientific proofs. Where is the combustion in your test...? Where is the particles in the engine? Where is the burnt carbon? Where is the seals? Where are the bearings where is the load forces in metals with higher temps...? Just in case you always take foreign brands to find the losers

          • Frank Alley
            Frank Alley  1 weeks back

            Might I suggest a minor change to your cold flow performance test? Freeze the race lanes too.

          • Fred Novak
            Fred Novak  1 weeks back

            I don't know why this was so entertaining.

          • OdinAF
            OdinAF  1 weeks back

            Amsoil Warranty is far superior to amazon.

          • WaynesMundo
            WaynesMundo  2 weeks back

            Fantastic video. One oil i've always held in high regard was the Total Quartz 9000 5w40. Maybe one for the test?

          • LALOMAN
            LALOMAN  2 weeks back

            You be crazy if i'm putting that Amazon basics shit oil inside my BMW! HELL TO THE NAH NAH NA NA NAHHHHHH!!!

            Amazon basics oil is made of 70% water, 20% Crisco and 10% Dog shit!

            • jeremy pearson
              jeremy pearson  2 weeks back

              Your wife is probably wondering why the coffee tastes different lately....lol

            • Giuseppe Ragona
              Giuseppe Ragona  2 weeks back

              The best oil for suv 5w30?

              • Project Farm
                Project Farm   2 weeks back

                Amsoil Signature #1, Pennzoil Ultra #2

            • TGE
              TGE  2 weeks back

              Was thinkin' when usin' the bearing test stamp bearings for w/e oil n reuse 'em rotated however many degrees..should get about 4 tests out of each

            • P Joubert
              P Joubert  2 weeks back

              You skipped the most important test. Which of these oils would be best for a Fryolator on Cape Cod in the summer? We're concerned about excessive evaporation. Ernie's Clam Shack, Provicetown.

            • Som&Shu 솜앤슈
              Som&Shu 솜앤슈  2 weeks back

              Please test joe gibbs new. Oil DI30

              • wenn wenn
                wenn wenn  2 weeks back

                Maybe Liqui Moly failed because of all those European specifications? 1:27

              • In2thePickers
                In2thePickers  2 weeks back

                How about rock auto house brand oil

              • Alaa Sibai
                Alaa Sibai  3 weeks back

                Great test. Thank you for sharing. I'm interested in seeing the same test performed on these two brands after 5k miles of usage. Just to see long term performance.

              • MrWilsonxD
                MrWilsonxD  3 weeks back

                More Amazon oil full synthetic comparisons please!

                • sprinter1313
                  sprinter1313  3 weeks back

                  amazon basic oil in americans tesla. ha ha

                  • Auto H 203
                    Auto H 203  3 weeks back

                    1. It-s LIQUI, not LiquiD moly
                    2. Liqui moly has synthetis tehnology so not fully synthetic.
                    The Synthoil range from liqui moly are the synthetics.

                  • The barbarian turk
                    The barbarian turk  3 weeks back

                    moly very nice..2016 gsxr600 👍 10w40

                  • Greta Thunfisch
                    Greta Thunfisch  3 weeks back

                    For me: Lique Moly wins

                  • czhff9
                    czhff9  3 weeks back

                    Liqui Moly also lost the evaporative test as it lost 0.609% versus Amazon Basics 0.604% loss (based on your before and after weights).

                    You may want to consider using percent loss as your starting weights differed on both the lubricity and evaporative tests.

                  • Mahmoud Abdulrazzak
                    Mahmoud Abdulrazzak  3 weeks back

                    Please try the nano engine protection from protec

                  • TCTerribleDog
                    TCTerribleDog  4 weeks back

                    Best episode ever.

                  • Barış Özbek
                    Barış Özbek  4 weeks back

                    İt is better to prepare an excel table to show all the results of products.This upgrades your experiments.

                  • Sebastian Tevel
                    Sebastian Tevel  4 weeks back

                    You have already done an incredible amount of work for these tests.
                    Next step.... would be a wear test after cooking the oil.
                    I think that would be more relevant than doing the test with brand new oils.
                    Nevertheless, thank you very much for the hard work!

                    • amar tita
                      amar tita  4 weeks back

                      Watch and read comment

                    • amar tita
                      amar tita  4 weeks back

                      Nice vid

                    • Dan Savitski
                      Dan Savitski  4 weeks back

                      It's too expensive for my mercades I just use castrol.now way cheaper and.just as good.if not.better

                      • Jim Talor
                        Jim Talor  1 months back

                        600+ thumbs down from the fancy label fans!

                      • Danny L
                        Danny L  1 months back

                        your channel is one of my top 5 channels out of hundreds.. thanks for all you do!

                      • Reddylion
                        Reddylion  1 months back

                        nice video.

                      • ChuChuTrain
                        ChuChuTrain  1 months back

                        I use mobile1 is it bad if i switch to amazon now?

                      • Forchan Chan
                        Forchan Chan  1 months back

                        Dear Lord. I just bought Liqui Moly 5L for my 1.8T. Payed 55$

                      • Jack  Black
                        Jack Black  1 months back

                        NOT A FAIR TEST!Obviously this is their diesel
                        Oil but because of their additives also can be used on SOME gas vehicles. Very obvious when you don’t even see an approval
                        Rating for Gas engine Mercedes,229.3,229.5,and most of the ratings on the label
                        Are for Diesel engines.So this was no way a fair test.Seems so many people are out to push red line and amsoil.2 companies that give away their products for free to people to push them.Not saying your doing this but I can run E85 and 93 octane in my car. Would that be a fair test to see Wich will clean my valves better?Why don’t you use their Gas only oil,rated only for gas engines and to make it fair how about newgen their latest oil or even go back to the older oils like high Tec. By the way redline and amsoil buy their oils from BP Shell and Mobile whoever’s barrel
                        Is cheaper that day,already refined. People actually think redline and amsoil Have refineries and wells digging in the gulf for only the best crude,ha ha. And they take that oil they buy in barrels and simply add their additives tryng to out add the other. That’s why their oils cost double mobile 1 liqui moly Castrol etc.It’s all a oil company racket that other people get paid to push.Change your oil at 3-5k instead of the crazy 10-15k and neither of these oils or pretty much any decent oil even non synthetic will outperform the other.If your dumb enough to wait 15k your car will never see 200k,the additives in the SUPERMAN amsoil and BATMAN redline and all the oils might help some,but can’t save you from sludge blown headgaskets valve issues and timing chain breaks,all issues attributed to lazy cheap ass people who don’t wana spend $30 every few k to change the blood in their car. Now go buy some liquigen moly and do this test again!By the way the amazon oil won the ruler test but when your engine is HOTT you want the THICKER OIL!!So you don’t blow a rod or bearing!Thats the point of liqui moly to protect your motor when your driving it. What do you do more start your car in the cold to warm it up for 5 minutes or DRIVE IT while the oil is COOKING!?Ill take the thick protection during actually using the the car driving it on highway high rpm city driving stop and go over a quick half second start In 15 degrees. I mean liquid moly actually won the better oil test truth be told. It lost the cold start BUT BIG BUT,being it was thicker that means it also stuck to the pistons rods lifter all the crucial parts better DEFINITELY MOST LIKELY. So did it really win the cold start test??The Amazon oil over night left a less protective coating due to it being lighter. Who cares if this oil or that is The thinnest at cold start I want the oil that will have little bit left over on the engine parts for when I start it In below zero weather. You think that oil in the pan is gonna help you immediately?It was still thick barely thinner then moly. What protects you is the oil film left over from when you parked it overnight from the thicker oil. I don’t care how thin the oil was,if it left no film your engine will instantly sound like a diesel knock knock-who’s there-Rod-Rod who-ROD KNOCK!
                        Ha ha ha

                      • De-bodgery
                        De-bodgery  1 months back

                        mobile 1, castrol edge, amazon basics, penzoil platinum, castrol GTX, valvoline full synthetic, and royal purple 51530: all in one showdown video.

                      • BTK Google
                        BTK Google  1 months back

                        Great video as are all of your productions. I find them entertaining as well as informative. I do not buy any product that you have run tests on until I review your conclusions. Perhaps a video on DEF Fluid? Another great video would be to find out which of the battery powered power tools has the best battery charge hold and battery overall battery life:)

                        • Hanynowsky
                          Hanynowsky  1 months back

                          I am going to tell you a secret about liqui moly toptec category.
                          I have been using it in my BMWs.
                          I tested Castrol, Motul, Mebanol, BMW Oil, Shell Helix...
                          Liqui Moly oil needs at least 500 kms before its formula takes a stable shape that would lubricate the engine as optimally as possible without loosing protection and viscocity chracteristics.
                          You should run these oils in the same car for at least 500 kms, then grab a portion of each and re-do your tests. You will be suprised.
                          Besides, LM toptec 4200 is BMW LL04 compliant (fuel without sulfur), while Amazon basics is BMW LL01 (fuel with sulfur).
                          You can retry the test with LM special tec 5w30 if you r in USA.