Doug DeMuro’s Take on New Cars vs. Used Cars

  • Published: 08 February 2019
  • Should you buy new cars or used cars? Doug DeMuro provides his opinions on whether people should buy new or used cars, and gives his take on when people should get new cars and when they should get used ones.

    Facebook -
    Twitter -
    Instagram -


Comments • 5 063

  • Lil jamezZz
    Lil jamezZz  13 hours back

    *buy used car*
    *save money for new car*
    *buy new car*

    • dlw3m
      dlw3m  5 days back

      A good one

      • Josh Peterson
        Josh Peterson  5 days back

        I buy old cars for cheap and I buy what I want and what I can get a good deal on. I don't care about safety so much. If I die in a car, I will be dying doing what I love haha!

        • chris corona
          chris corona  1 weeks back

          Doug just killed me like 10 times, lol i drive an 80s Mercedes Diesel.

          • Ivo Jara
            Ivo Jara  1 weeks back

            During my life i have bought several used cars, mostly returned cars from dealerships, these are cars with 1.000 to 4.000 miles in the odo. People returned them because they didn´t like them, or they had ratltes or noises that were not solved by the dealership service. Usually 30% to 40% chaper than new.

            • Edward Aguirre
              Edward Aguirre  2 weeks back

              Motor vehicle fatality per 100,000 population in the year 1998 was 15.36%

              Motor vehicle fatality per 100,000 population in the year 2018 was 11.18%

              If safety is a concern, get a bus pass. Or a tank.

              • K T
                K T  3 weeks back

                Doug the type of guy who wants his wife to ride a black wood lol

                • Pierre Roberge
                  Pierre Roberge  1 months back

                  So well explained. Good job my man.

                  • Kaylie Sellers
                    Kaylie Sellers  1 months back

                    Lmao, 76 Scott's os my daily. 84 harley is my weekends. And my 78 camino is my fun times. S th ick the safety right where the sun dont shine girly man.

                    • dishwasher soap
                      dishwasher soap  1 months back

                      Senor doug I working construction I u for u cheap
                      Paint : 100$
                      Drywall :599$
                      Sink :195$
                      Bathroom new :5k
                      I working in DC call me I speaka english good

                      • marty podolsky
                        marty podolsky  1 months back

                        LINCOLN BLACKWOOD!

                        • Donnie Baynard
                          Donnie Baynard  1 months back

                          One more thing, you say you don't have biases about cars. Uhhhh.... you're definitely biased to German makes and models for whatever reason.

                          • Donnie Baynard
                            Donnie Baynard  1 months back

                            One or two year old cars have virtually the same tech, so you don't lose all the money on the up front depreciation. All the autonomy of the cars aren't for safety, it's for control. My honest opinion.

                            • Donnie Baynard
                              Donnie Baynard  1 months back

                              Streetspeed717 just lost 40,000 in no time on a McClaren 600lt. Just sayin.

                              • Arcade Sunday
                                Arcade Sunday  1 months back

                                Great take on new vs new. I'm in the budget group. Get a used car and am willing to repair some stuff myself for cheaper than a mechanic. I guess we're in the minority. Collegues of mine are the type who just pay more for a newer car, and trade it in for a newer one before it has a problem. I kind of wish I was "them" but from a cash point of view, my method works for me. Repairing my coolant system as I type this. Well, not right now... My hands are full of antifreeze. Thanks for another great video.

                                • first name
                                  first name  2 months back

                                  "Yeah that's true... until you're DEAD"

                                  • drwisdom1
                                    drwisdom1  2 months back

                                    The nuance Mr. DeMuro doesn't account for is that almost all modern cars are equipped with the feature of death (automatic transmission) that wants to kill you or put you to sleep. Almost all post ABS/traction control safety features are trying to mitigate the situations automatic transmissions put you in. If you have a 10 year old car with a manual you are safer than a new vehicle with an automatic and tons of safety features. The truth is modern vehicles and all their tech are distraction machines.

                                    So my friend's office is next to a Ford dealership. Some years back the Blackwood pickup trucks didn't sell, so to liquidate they dropped the price and he bought a new one for $25k. It was an awful truck. It got poor gas mileage and its tank wasn't big so you had to fill up after 200 miles. It had showboat lights filling the bed so it was a pickup truck that couldn't carry stuff. It had lots of power so you had to be careful to not give it gas on corners or the rear end would set loose. But whenever we went shopping, when we returned to the truck there were women looking at it like they needed one more than a dozen pair of nice shoes. That is the vehicle Mr. DeMuro considers buying?

                                    • Nathan Gaumer
                                      Nathan Gaumer  2 months back

                                      The first owner of my wife's 2016 rav4 with 20k miles lost $150 of value every time they filled the fuel tank.

                                      • james Gand
                                        james Gand  2 months back

                                        This is something that no one talks about. It is such a nice feeling knowing you have blind spot detection, forward collision warning, airbags in the car where it's needed. A few of those features has saved my life. Having a modern car will always be a huge advantage.

                                        • Nick Fusco
                                          Nick Fusco  2 months back

                                          I couldn’t agree more with your points. I’m the CPO guy and probably always will be.

                                          • Lemon
                                            Lemon  2 months back

                                            Yoz cant tell me that getting a used car that was released in 2017 for 10k€ is worse the buying a new car for 20K+€ that is brand new....

                                            • Mirotvorez113
                                              Mirotvorez113  2 months back

                                              Everybody are always so concerned about car safety. With healthcare in US if I get into serious accident, it better be fatal. So lack of safety is a plus for me.

                                              • richau
                                                richau  2 months back

                                                i drive a diesel corolla, have had brand new car, have had turbo car, corolla the best i ever bought, if i die i die, but heres how it will go: i will keep my corolla 20 more years and when i have enought money a second car with huge turbo and rear wheeel drive

                                                • DOICES
                                                  DOICES  2 months back

                                                  If you want the latest and greatest but used.
                                                  3-4 years old with anything under 45k miles is your best bet.
                                                  Anything can be a beater just like my 72 Maverick, absolute workhorse.

                                                  • Sherry Carpenter
                                                    Sherry Carpenter  2 months back

                                                    Great video Doug. I get it, Move in ready for you right,LOL.

                                                    • Ron M
                                                      Ron M  2 months back

                                                      Great analysis. All his points are bang on.

                                                      • Matthew Spencer
                                                        Matthew Spencer  2 months back

                                                        I think you can get a safer 10 year old, 60,000 mile, used car for $7,000 than you would new for the same price.

                                                        Assuming apples and oranges, buy the better things. But if your budget can't stretch then a ugly, unpopular model can give you a lot of bang for your buck in the used market.

                                                        My V35 (G35) looks uglier than a brick. Gets me from A-B safely and quickly though. 10/10 would put a paper bag over again.

                                                        • Shaun
                                                          Shaun  2 months back

                                                          It's all an attack on Scotty Kilmer.

                                                          • woget264
                                                            woget264  2 months back

                                                            Hating maintence is a big plus for an EV, not much to maintain on those machines.

                                                            • Max Ant
                                                              Max Ant  2 months back

                                                              Worst dressed YouTuber.

                                                              • Bill Coulter
                                                                Bill Coulter  2 months back

                                                                Give ‘em hell Doug!😎

                                                                • Mr JKL
                                                                  Mr JKL  2 months back

                                                                  I’m an enthusiast but whenever I buy my mom a car I tend to go with CPO. My wife is the same but I’m the only one that’ll look at an old AMG and say “I want that” and in some ways you can get away with the safety features because Mercedes is usually the first to have them way longer than other males but you’ll have to have deep pockets if it breaks but that’s part of the charm.

                                                                  • craigmak
                                                                    craigmak  2 months back

                                                                    Buying a new car is moronic for all types. A new RC-F is $80,000. A 2015 is $35,000. A 5 year old Lexus is not going to give you headaches. $45,000 is a ridiculous amount of money to throw in the trash. This applies to all makes and models.

                                                                    • Ben Bauer
                                                                      Ben Bauer  2 months back

                                                                      Or you could buy an Alfa Romeo and have that shiny new car AND work on it.

                                                                      • Lynda Moss
                                                                        Lynda Moss  2 months back

                                                                        Keepin' it real, bro! ❤️

                                                                        • Ghost Gutarist
                                                                          Ghost Gutarist  2 months back

                                                                          This guy thinks the Used car means a 10-Year-old Used car. You can do better than this Doug

                                                                          • arthwys
                                                                            arthwys  2 months back

                                                                            He nails it on the head for me when he eventually got around to certified used. I bought a 2013 F-150 Lariat crew cab 4x4 off road for 29,000 a year ago, certified used. Original price? 54 thousand. If I had purchased new spending 29,000 I'd have ended up with a base model without all the trimmings I now have with the one I bought.

                                                                            • Larry La Bella
                                                                              Larry La Bella  2 months back

                                                                              Living in NY I can't afford a new car because all that $ goes into ridiculous high taxes .1.500 a month for a 2000 square foot house . We will be amongst all those running out of NYS .
                                                                              Only then can I afford a new vehicle .

                                                                              • Sumit Shrestha
                                                                                Sumit Shrestha  2 months back

                                                                                u sure its 95 Corolla? i think you mean 95 celica.

                                                                                • Will Stikken
                                                                                  Will Stikken  2 months back

                                                                                  Many of the new "safety feature" on my wife's new car are anything but. They're distractions that often promote bad habits over basic driving skills and in some instances interfere with the driver. Not all are bad but i can't see me driving daily with all these things engaged not to mention while the drive train may last for these newer cars arent going to age well or have the longer life of older cars.

                                                                                  • dmc7173
                                                                                    dmc7173  2 months back

                                                                                    The best automotive financial move you can make is to buy an 8 year old toyota.

                                                                                    • Jay Raj Shetty
                                                                                      Jay Raj Shetty  2 months back

                                                                                      So many personal finance people are offended over here in the comments.

                                                                                      A used car has many risks. I'm in the process of getting myself my first car and the risks that come with it are making me gravitate towards a new one.

                                                                                      The only true argument for used cars is depreciation.

                                                                                      I mean, the point of a car is to get you from A to B at your own convinience. The convinience is what you're paying for....for the extra amount you pay for in a new car, you get peace of mind, warranty, manufacture guarantee, a product that you get to maintain by yourself. That is worth it.

                                                                                      Certified pre-owned covers the warranty but that too is for a shorter time frame.

                                                                                      • Sean Archer
                                                                                        Sean Archer  2 months back

                                                                                        Safety is a bullshit argument. New vs used is more of a brand new or a few years used... 1994 Corolla... Anyone who buys that does so because they don't have a choice, not because it's the smarter financial decision...

                                                                                        • Dave Coons
                                                                                          Dave Coons  2 months back

                                                                                          I think you nailed it. Get one a couple of years old, still has a warranty, bugs worked out.

                                                                                          Only downside, you can't specify the options you want. You are stuck with what is available. Want a blue 5.0 Mustang auto with adaptive cruise control and leather? Sorry, none available in your town.

                                                                                          • Honesty Counts
                                                                                            Honesty Counts  2 months back

                                                                                            Oh yeah, I can tell that your priority in life is NOT on fine clothes!

                                                                                            • coalie roller
                                                                                              coalie roller  2 months back

                                                                                              I had to buy used because the car I want no longer in production

                                                                                              • Steve Drawdy
                                                                                                Steve Drawdy  2 months back

                                                                                                Dave Ramsey has entered the chat

                                                                                                • Raphael
                                                                                                  Raphael  2 months back

                                                                                                  For me, the sweet spot is two years old. Almost a full warranty, but the worst of the depreciation is done, getting me a good price.