What rule in soccer has VAR impacted the most? | Extra Time

Share
HTML-code
  • Published: 11 January 2020
  • ESPN FC's Adrian Healey, Shaka Hislop, Stewart Robson and Craig Burley take fan questions during Extra Time including: If the guys could change one rule in soccer what would it be and why, (3:00) if Craig is a better football player or if Rod Stewart is a better singer, (7:04) what the guys' least favorite thing about soccer today is, (11:00) and how Shaka feels about David Moyes wanting to bring Marouane Fellaini back to the Premier League.

    ✔ Subscribe to ESPN FC on YouTube: http://bit.ly/SUBSCRIBEtoESPNFC
  • Sport Sport

Comments • 77

  • George Smith
    George Smith  2 weeks back

    This is a tearful panel

    • Mike Beaver
      Mike Beaver  3 weeks back

      have a free substitution for head injuries

      • Gary Weber
        Gary Weber  3 weeks back

        Grealish, chilwell, mings, sañcho

        • Muggle Ting
          Muggle Ting  3 weeks back

          The word soccer was made by an English man in the 19th century, yet theres a whole lot of English people in the comments bitching about it 😄

          • smanslam1
            smanslam1  3 weeks back

            That was a long extra time, no penalty shoot out?!
            Interesting though.

            • Stuart Penman
              Stuart Penman  3 weeks back

              Jeffery Epstein had Catapedaphobia

              • andrew garabedian
                andrew garabedian  3 weeks back

                Thank god blue jacket isn't on

                • Benedict Chinweuba
                  Benedict Chinweuba  3 weeks back

                  The offside

                  • hanshal sethi
                    hanshal sethi  3 weeks back

                    Calling football "soccer" is murder. And USA think why not their League is given importance "MLS".

                    • Carl Reyes
                      Carl Reyes  3 weeks back

                      6:36
                      "Its hard to bluff goalkeepers,do you know why? Because its hard to get into their heads, because they're goalkeepers for a reason.They're stupid." How did they miss that one 🤣🤣

                      • Chvncey
                        Chvncey  3 weeks back

                        Carl Reyes Shaka tends to speak over him before he can really hit that punchline lol

                    • Solar Storm
                      Solar Storm  3 weeks back

                      It's Pronounced football!!!!!

                      • anthony doyle
                        anthony doyle  3 weeks back

                        Fouls that make no attempt to play the ball and only intent is to take out the ball carrier should be a straight red. It’s cynical it’s not in the spirit of the game and it’s dangerous. We’ve all seen it when your team breaks and some opposition player thinks it’s a goal scoring opportunity and decides to rugby tackle your player. It’s currently a yellow card but sometimes it needs to be more punishing, not based on how good a chance it was, but by how little attempt was made to play the ball

                        • Magrin Barrie
                          Magrin Barrie  3 weeks back

                          a millimetre is an advantage, craig.

                          • whitey 604
                            whitey 604  3 weeks back

                            I'm fine with the offside rule, whether it's an inch or an armpit it's offside. People have to deal with it. My problem is the handballs, ever since the first Fifa Tourney that had VAR I knew it was gonna be a problem.

                            • Mostafa Maki
                              Mostafa Maki  3 weeks back

                              Thanks for taking my question!

                            • Tim Guerra
                              Tim Guerra  3 weeks back

                              Honestly the only clowns who ever bring up how they hate the word “soccer” are just 12 year olds or bitter old people

                              • anthony doyle
                                anthony doyle  3 weeks back

                                Got to agree with savage, football has billions of fans who don’t need the word soccer to clarify what we are talking about only yanks. NFL isn’t even the most popular sport from your country and worldwide more ppl watch cricket, table tennis and dare I say rugby.

                              • Anti-Hero
                                Anti-Hero  3 weeks back

                                No, people who know about football origin and its history.

                            • Hoje Tive Cá
                              Hoje Tive Cá  3 weeks back

                              Whenever a team has a red carded player, they should be allowed to introduce a NEW player on to the field either 30 minutes after the expulsion or when the opposing team scored a goal: whichever came 1st. Stoppage time DOES NOT COUNT to the 30 minutes, btw. If the red carded player gets his card after minute 60, unless there's extra time in that game (depends on the game: an FA Cup game can have extra time, for example) and the opposing team doesn't score a goal, then that team plays with a player less for the rest of the game.
                              IMO: such a change would benefit the game.

                              • I S
                                I S  3 weeks back

                                What’s soccer?

                                • andrew tucker
                                  andrew tucker  3 weeks back

                                  Make it rolling subs I.e. you can come back on an a bench of 6 much faster and more attacking

                                  • andrew tucker
                                    andrew tucker  3 weeks back

                                    Get rid of offside full stop

                                    • Callum Neill
                                      Callum Neill  3 weeks back

                                      What's soccer? Sounds like a yankeedoodle thing

                                      • Muggle Ting
                                        Muggle Ting  3 weeks back

                                        The word soccer was made by an English man in the 19th century

                                    • andrew tucker
                                      andrew tucker  3 weeks back

                                      My rule VAR MUST DISPLAY MORE COMMON SENSE!!!

                                      • alan duncan
                                        alan duncan  3 weeks back

                                        When are you going to learn to stop using that S word? 😠

                                        • SupremeJas
                                          SupremeJas  3 weeks back

                                          Probably offsides, I feel like for an arm to be considered offside, the ONLY part of the body you can’t use in football is bs

                                          • anthony doyle
                                            anthony doyle  3 weeks back

                                            SupremeJas as far as I’m aware you cannot be offside by your arm as you cannot score with it, but your shoulder can be offside as you can score with it, for me the offside rule is black and white so fine with that,and most complaints are about the margins now being small and the technology not being precise enough. All that said and done I would tinker the rule so offside only looks at your leg position and ignore every other part of the body as the only time I feel VAR have been unfair with an offside in the EPL was Timo Pukki vs Tottenham, his anticipation was excellent and in this example a great goal was ruled out correctly but unfairly

                                        • HanzSygnal
                                          HanzSygnal  3 weeks back

                                          This is best trio on the channel

                                          • Yusuf
                                            Yusuf  3 weeks back

                                            If a player scores directly from an offside position then it shouldn't be a goal even if it's mm. But if he's offside by mm then runs and scores from an onside position then it should be a goal.

                                            • ppa p lalalalalalalalala

                                              Shaka looking thic today ;)

                                              • Only4comments
                                                Only4comments  3 weeks back

                                                No separate VAR referees. Let the on field ref. take a second look without drawing the lines for offside.

                                                • Muhammad Tijani
                                                  Muhammad Tijani  3 weeks back

                                                  Yh but the subs one will be time consuming it will reduce game time

                                                  • Muhammad Tijani
                                                    Muhammad Tijani  3 weeks back

                                                    @FIFA Machine am really not sure about that but nevermind it won't happen anyway.

                                                  • FIFA Machine
                                                    FIFA Machine  3 weeks back

                                                    Muhammad Tijani game time will stay the same as subs only come on when the ball is out of play

                                                • Ex Essex
                                                  Ex Essex  3 weeks back

                                                  The offside rule is there to prevent "goal hanging". Measuring the position of players' toes, elbows etc. is ridiculous and completely ignores the original intention of the offside rule. Scrap VAR, I say.

                                                  • marinerphil xavi
                                                    marinerphil xavi  3 weeks back

                                                    Lol... i like the idea of playing around subs. Allowing players to come in and go off at any time 😁

                                                    • Anti-Hero
                                                      Anti-Hero  3 weeks back

                                                      Remove "soccer" from the title immediately!

                                                      • The Vaskon
                                                        The Vaskon  3 weeks back

                                                        John Cena im pretty sure muggle is right man. It was derived from association football

                                                      • John Cena
                                                        John Cena  3 weeks back

                                                        Muggle Ting no the Americans changed it to soccer because they had their own football which is basically American rugby, they just didn’t want another sport to be called football

                                                      • Muggle Ting
                                                        Muggle Ting  3 weeks back

                                                        The word soccer was made by an English man in the 19th century

                                                      • Muggle Ting
                                                        Muggle Ting  3 weeks back

                                                        The word soccer was made by an English man in the 19th century

                                                      • Anti-Hero
                                                        Anti-Hero  3 weeks back

                                                        @alan duncan 😂

                                                    • Edgar el takuache
                                                      Edgar el takuache  3 weeks back

                                                      it's not soccer it's football you idiots

                                                      • Liam H
                                                        Liam H  3 weeks back

                                                        It's a ref watching the video in the end. It's just the same human error, but now it takes longer and is an unnecessary expense. AI.R. is the way to go

                                                        • Aaron Soza
                                                          Aaron Soza  3 weeks back

                                                          Only thing being impacted is Barca winning 😂 always cheating

                                                          • Abi
                                                            Abi  3 weeks back

                                                            You think you're so funny, don't you.

                                                        • oskar hall
                                                          oskar hall  3 weeks back

                                                          Roll in the ‘soccer’ hate comments....

                                                        • wweepp
                                                          wweepp  3 weeks back

                                                          SoCcEr

                                                          • Jadon Not Sancho
                                                            Jadon Not Sancho  3 weeks back

                                                            It's so displeasing to the ear to call the beautiful game 'soccer'🤢

                                                            • Jadon Not Sancho
                                                              Jadon Not Sancho  3 weeks back

                                                              @Muggle Ting biggest mistake of his life

                                                            • Muggle Ting
                                                              Muggle Ting  3 weeks back

                                                              The word soccer was made by an English man in the 19th century

                                                            • Chvncey
                                                              Chvncey  3 weeks back

                                                              Yeah it's not like we don't have different dialects or anything.

                                                            • XhoowieX
                                                              XhoowieX  3 weeks back

                                                              @benny Hampton you're making fun of people being upset by the term 'soccer' in the same comment as calling the word 'soccer' the 2nd most obnoxious thing in the world...

                                                            • Kurushi ai
                                                              Kurushi ai  3 weeks back

                                                              Brooo stfu literally no one cares... its the US we call it soccer here, stop crying

                                                          • Gindie wye
                                                            Gindie wye  3 weeks back

                                                            Just remove bar it is like neymar injury

                                                            • Nissan GTR
                                                              Nissan GTR  3 weeks back

                                                              Its criminal to call it soccer.

                                                              • Muggle Ting
                                                                Muggle Ting  3 weeks back

                                                                Why? The word soccer was made by an English man in the 19th century

                                                            • layton4xi
                                                              layton4xi  3 weeks back

                                                              Football

                                                              • Angel5999
                                                                Angel5999  3 weeks back

                                                                Who’s been a fan before 2020 ❤️❤️

                                                                👇❤️


                                                                Gifting my next 10 subscribers❤️❤️

                                                                • Angel5999
                                                                  Angel5999  3 weeks back

                                                                  Who’s been a fan before 2020 ❤️❤️

                                                                  👇❤️

                                                                  Gifting my next 10 subscribers❤️❤️